Front | Back |
1. How do news media’s “secondary claims” differ from claimsmakers
“primary claims”?
|
primary claims are from claimsmakers who want media attention
media’s secondary claims are the media version of primary
claims. Follow the same structure as primary claims (presenting grounds,
typifying examples, stats, giving social problem a name), but are different in
that they are:
shorter
more dramatic
less ideological
|
2. Who are “dispossessed” claimsmakers?
|
Claimsmakers defined by the media as lacking the legitimacy to deserve
coverage for one or more of the following reasons:
·
Are poor or lack high status, wealth, power
·
Have views that are considered too far outside
the mainstream—too unpopular or too radical; “fringe views” (ex: person
supporting change from democracy to socialism)
·
Have views that don’t appeal to news media’s
target audience
Often ignored by media outlets and have a hard time gaining media
coverage, especially from media outlets that have a large audience
|
3. What factors make a story “newsworthy”?
|
factors reflect facet of everyday knowledge, what people pay attention to
·
interesting
·
relates to audience’s lives and beliefs
·
novel, exciting, new
|
4. What is sociocentrism and how does it affect
news? (Paul & Elder)
|
sociocentrism- viewing our own culture’s perspective on issues as more
factual than others; social conventions, beliefs, taboos seen as “the only
correct way to think and live”
·
is a fundamental characteristic of all
countries and cultures; and in order to be financially successful, media
outlets must sell stories that are popular to the public, therefore stories are
biased toward their country’s “allies,” and prejudiced against their “enemies.”
happens in all countries and cultures.
·
media presents events occurring in the countries
of their allies in as favorable a light as possible, highlighting “positive”
deeds while downplaying negative ones; and do the opposite when generating news
stories about their enemies
|
5. What is “slant” in news coverage? Why is it important? Example? (Paul
& Elder)
|
slant- using words, phrases, etc used to reinforce the prevailing views
among the readership or audience for whom they are writing
·
important because stories with slant do not
present an un-biased opinion, often readers don’t get the full story,
audience’s opinions are decided for them by the media, and leads to sociocentrism
·
Examples: We plan…They plot. We are clever…They
are sneaky. We form strategies…They conspire. We have convictions…They are
fanatics.
|
6. Why does public opinion matter? Who pays attention to it? Best fig. 187?
|
Public opinion influences media coverage, policy making, and
politics
Claimsmakers, the media, and policymakers want to shape and
influence public opinion, but they also pay attention to the public’s reactions
and try to adjust their own behavior in response
|
8. Does public opinion correspond better with actual events or with media
coverage? Can you give an example that supports your answer?
|
Public opinion corresponds better with media coverage, studies of crime
and illegal drug use show that public concern may be rising even when rates of
crime and drug use were falling, and that people’s concern was more closely
correlated to increased media coverage of the problems
|
9. According to Gilens, what do Americans overestimate when they
characterize the poor? What evidence does he use? In rough estimates, how far
off is our characterization? How do misunderstandings of poverty affect poverty
policies?
|
·
We think majority of poor are black
·
We said 50%, but actually only 29%
·
We think majority are working age, able-bodied
Because of stereotypes about who we think are the poor, we are less
sympathetic and less inclined to help
|
10. Policymakers and the public are similar in many ways. What is the one
most important difference between members of the public and policymakers?
|
Are “organizational actors” do not act as an individual, but in a role as
a actor. Cannot simply look at an issue from their own viewpoint
|
11. Why is it useful for claimsmakers to claim that the middle
class is the victim of a social problem?
|
Middle class is the largest target audience for media, and it gains the attention of the public
|
12. What type of arguments do policymakers favor?
|
Those that appeal to widespread audience, provide a measurable and
plausible solution
|
14. When did homelessness become a major issue? What factors lead up to
it?
|
1970’s
·
mainly due to unavailability of affordable
housing for poor people
·
Community Mental Health Act of 1963, which led
to many homeless living on streets, unemployed, with drug and alcohol
addictions, and no resources to change their living conditions
|
15. What is the composition of the homeless population in the U.S? In
Colorado?
|
25% of all homeless in U.S are children and teens (28% of this
percentage live in CO)
59% of all homeless in U.S are single parents
|
16. What is the “power distribution of homelessness”? How does this idea
influence Gladwell’s ideas for solving homelessness?
|
Homelessness doesn’t have a normal distribution , has power-law
distribution—80% of homeless only stay for one to two days max at a time and
never come back, other 10% are periodically homeless and are often young drug
users, last 10% are stereotypical homeless (panhandling, sleeping on streets,
older and often are mentally ill or physically disabled) that account for the
majority of $$ spent on homelessness)
·
Therefore policy should not have normal
distribution—policy should help those who cost most money to help, power-law
theory is different from other policies because should create dependency, is
effective and rational from a economic standpoint, but not from a moral
standpoint
·
Giving them an apartment and nurses costs less
than leaving them on the street
|
17. Who are “social problems workers”? How are they different from other
players in the social problems process?
|
People whose jobs involve carrying out social policies, ex: doctors,
teachers, police officers, etc. have a more narrow view of social problems:
applying constructions of social problems or policies to their immediate,
practical situations
·
Are different because policymakers, media,
public, and claimsmakers tend to characterize social problems in fairly
abstract, general terms, and tend to focus on the implications of troubling
condition for the larger society, take a macrosociological view
|