Front | Back |
Important questions and concepts for World System and Desire
|
How does global production/consumption
shape opportunities for individuals and relationships between nations?
Three commodities – broccoli, sushi and
cocaine (and how their trade affects relationships)
Global Connections – production,
consumption, desire (three interconnected themes of today’s readings)
|
Article: Cocaine and the Economic Deterioration of BoliviaAuthor: Weatherford
|
“The demands of the
world market have eroded local subsistence economies for centuries.” à
How so?
Bolivia – South
America – how does consumption of cocaine effect peasants in Bolivia (driving
question of article)
Coca Leaves –
traditionally grown and consumed as mild stimulant, cocaine – a heavily
processed narcotic derived from coca leaves
Agricultural village – Pocona (agricultural village),
Chapare (coca growing area) – people go to growing area to make money
Problem – when people get imbedded in coca growing economy,
people employing start supplying workers with drugs, become addicted, flow of
cash dries up
|
What are the impacts of cash cropping?
|
Rural villages
depleted of work force.
Families and
traditional cultural patterns disintegrate.
People can no longer
afford local products that suddenly become valued in the West.
From mild stimulant
to heavy intoxicant (coca leaves to beverages)
Barefooted pisacocas
stomping leaves soaked in kerosene, salt, acetone and sulfuric into paste
|
What are the health impacts for the cocaine farmers in Bolivia?
|
Young men become
permanently disabled:
Chemicals dissolve pisacocas skin so they lose use of feet
and hands.
|
What are the nutrition impacts of cocaine farming?
|
More land used for
coca production than food production (peasants must buy food) – peasants remove land from agricultural food production
to make coca leaves.
Impoverishment drains
labor from rural farming areas (loss of labor = less production).
|
What are the economic impacts of cocaine farming?
|
Rural poverty gets
worse (especially as the young and able become disabled).
Economic disparities
increase (those who control production/distribution profit).
Small farmers
targeted for growing more profitable coca.
|
Article: How Sushi Went GlobalAuthor: Bestor
|
(Atlantic
Bluefin Tuna)
How did this fish become
a highly sought after global commodity?
How did the
globalization of tuna change:
Economic practices
(e.g., fishing)
Consumption habits
(e.g., eating)Pre-global Tuna era
(1950s-1970s): cheap food, cat food
Companies trying to
convince you to eat this food – equated as cheap meat, even the government says
you should eat it, not a global commodity with much value
Points
Connects US, Japan in global network
Globalization is not
Westernization (flows of info/commodities/technologies go both ways).
Sushi = example of acculturation
in America of Japanese cuisine (long term contact, starting to borrow from each
other, starting to eat each others’ foods)
|
How has sushi's image changed in the USA?
|
From strange foreign
item (1970s – low demand)
To upscale fare
(1990s – high demand)
Americans changing
diets (less red meat)
Adapting to mnew
markets (Kosher sushi, cooked sushi, “California Roll”, etc.)
Connections with
socioeconomic class (marker economic standing and “worldliness”) – upper
middle, upper class food (prestige food), going to sushi bar says something
about your statusSushi so popular in the US today that you can go to grocery store,
can find the stuff to make sushi
|
What have been the impacts on fishing as a result of the rise in popularity of sushi?
|
International
competition for global commodity.
Creation of
international regulations to manage “stateless” fish that migrate extensively.
Development of new,
more intensive fishing techniques (e.g., traps and feed lots).
Changes in fishing
industry
|
How has transnational business/migration changed in response to the rise in popularity of sushi?
|
Business
relationships between Japanese buyers and American fishermen.
American fishermen impacted
by global markets (tuna prices).
Opportunities for
young Japanese to work abroad (sushi chef qualification = Japanese).
|
Article: Broccoli and DesireAuthors: Benson and Fischer
|
Lackluster vegetable
*Article looking at connection between Pablo and Susan (Pablo
– producer, Susan – consumer)
Fieldwork conducted among: smallholders and middlemen in Guatemala, grocery shoppers in Nashville, Tennessee (multi-sited ethnography)
Consumption, production – what ties them together?
Much research on globalization view the world thru this lens
(North – desire, affluence, South – need, poverty)
Exploiters – North, Exploited – South
**Not the lens used in this article
|
What is desire?
|
A “collective
phenomenon shaped by interface of individual intentions, local worlds, and
global flows.”
Desiring “is an
ongoing, future-oriented process.”
A project that seeks
to “make and remake the world around certain values.”
|
What shapes desires?
|
Desires specific to
local worlds
Yet local worlds are
part of larger systems of production and trade
Collective
Experiences, cultural images, political economic structures
Pablo and Susan’s
desires
I want to get ahead
and achieve something - Pablo
I want to be healthy,
responsible consumer – Susan
Pablo – local
experience of modernity – desire to belong in global economic system
Susan – desire to
live a conscientious life
|
Export Crops
|
A step beyond subsistence into market economy
Requires surplus
land.
Demand from abroad.
Market (prices,
information) controlled by corporations and middle men.
High risk, low
returns – payoff can be ok but could be wiped out.
|
How is wealth viewed/quantified in Guatemala by the smallholders?
|
Smallholders: family
farms where small amount of land is owned by the family which acts as the
primary unit of production.
Smallholders with
relatively large landholding are relatively
wealthy and can grow for foreign market.
Feed family with
milpa fields (basic subsistence crops such as corn, beans)
Achieve relative
affluence through export
|