Biological Explanations of Schizophrenia

BIOLOGICAL EXPLANATIONS
Genetic Hypothesis - basic assumptions

14 cards   |   Total Attempts: 188
  

Cards In This Set

Front Back
BIOLOGICAL EXPLANATIONS Genetics. Twin studies - what might be an appropriate hypothesis be for studies of monzygotic twins and dyzgotic twins?
There will be a significantly higher concordance rate in onset of Sz for monozygotic twins compared with dizygotic twins.
BIOLOGICAL EXPLANATIONS Genetics. Gottesman (1991) Twin study
Risk of schizophrenia depends on genes shared MZ twins: 48% DZ twins (one effected parent): 17% 2 parents: 46%However: Concordance is not 100% in MZ so other factors must play a part.
BIOLOGICAL EXPLANATIONS Genetics. Cardno et al (2002) twin study using Maudsley Twin Register
MZ twins: concordance of 26.5% DZ: 0%Strongly supports a genetic link.
BIOLOGICAL EXPLANATIONS
Genetics. Criticisms of twin studies:
Twins rare and only 1% of Mz twins will have Sz so...(small studies) No same diagnostic criteria so it is hard to compare results Different definitions for MZ and DZ Concordance rates calculated in different ways
BIOLOGICAL EXPLANATIONS Genetics. Adoption Studies. Tienary (1991) Procedures Results Conclusions
155 adopted children with schizophrenic parents Compared with children with non-schizophrenic parents 10% with schiz parents developed it 1% of other non-schiz developed it It is likely there is a genetic component
BIOLOGICAL EXPLANATIONS Biochemical factors
Dopamine Hypothesis
Dopamine neurons fire too easily/ too often Abnormally high number of D2 receptors.
BIOLOGICAL EXPLANATIONS Biochemical factors
Evidence for dopamine hypothesis
Supported by studies on effects of drugs:Phenothiazines (Blocks dopamine synapses)Clozapine (Also blocks dopamine receptors)L-Dopa (used for Parkinsons - increases dopamine and leads to similar effects to Sz)ALSOPost Mortems show increased dopaminePET scans - Wong etal found 2x dopamine in Sz brain not using drugs compared to Sz with drugs.
BIOLOGICAL EXPLANATIONS Issues with the dopamine hypothesis
Neuroimaging hasnt provided evidenceDrugs do not have the same effects on all people Post-mortem shows that schiz' that hadnt received anti-psychotics had normal levelsMost post mortems are on Sz who used drugs. Hard to know whether ^ dopamine cause or effect
BIOLOGICAL EXPLANATIONS Neuroanatomical factors
Enlarged ventricles
Torrey (2002), Schiz have 15% larger ventricles Could be result of poor brain development/ tissue damage
BIOLOGICAL EXPLANATIONS Neuroanatomical factors
Problems - cause or effect?
Copolov + Crook (2000), meta-analysis showed overlap between schiz and non-schiz sizes Lyon et al (1981), as dose of medication increased so did ventricles (so, did Sz cause change or the drugs?)Abnormalities are not found in all sufferers.
BIOLOGICAL EXPLANATIONS Neuroanatomical factors
Crow (1985) suggestion of two types of schizophrenia
Type 1: genetically inherited. Associated with dopamine dysfunction + possitive symptoms. Responds to antipsychotic medication. Type 2: neurodevelopmental disorder. Pre-natal/ Perinatal insults. Poor premorbid functioning. Negative symptoms. Doesnt respond wel to drugs.
BIOLOGICAL EXPLANATIONS - SUMMARY ISSUE
Diathesis Stress Model
Have genetic predisposition, but only develops after significant psychological stressors
BIOLOGICAL EXPLANATIONS - SUMMARY ISSUE
Reductionist criticism
Doesn't take into account other factors. Biology trying to find specific explanations even to single genetic level (however, biologists do accept importance of other factors)
BIOLOGICAL EXPLANATIONS - SUMMARY ISSUE
Determinism criticism
Diathesis-stress model is accepted by most biologists Predisposition-but may not get it.