Front | Back |
BIOLOGICAL EXPLANATIONS
Genetics.
Twin studies - what might be an appropriate hypothesis be for studies of monzygotic twins and dyzgotic twins?
|
There will be a significantly higher concordance rate in onset of Sz for monozygotic twins compared with dizygotic twins.
|
BIOLOGICAL EXPLANATIONS
Genetics.
Gottesman (1991) Twin study
|
Risk of schizophrenia depends on genes shared
MZ twins: 48%
DZ twins (one effected parent): 17%
2 parents: 46%However: Concordance is not 100% in MZ so other factors must play a part.
|
BIOLOGICAL EXPLANATIONS
Genetics.
Cardno et al (2002) twin study using Maudsley Twin Register
|
MZ twins: concordance of 26.5%
DZ: 0%Strongly supports a genetic link.
|
BIOLOGICAL EXPLANATIONS
Genetics. Criticisms of twin studies: |
Twins rare and only 1% of Mz twins will have Sz so...(small studies)
No same diagnostic criteria so it is hard to compare results
Different definitions for MZ and DZ
Concordance rates calculated in different ways
|
BIOLOGICAL EXPLANATIONS
Genetics.
Adoption Studies. Tienary (1991)
Procedures
Results
Conclusions
|
155 adopted children with schizophrenic parents
Compared with children with non-schizophrenic parents
10% with schiz parents developed it
1% of other non-schiz developed it
It is likely there is a genetic component
|
BIOLOGICAL EXPLANATIONS
Biochemical factors
Dopamine Hypothesis |
Dopamine neurons fire too easily/ too often
Abnormally high number of D2 receptors.
|
BIOLOGICAL EXPLANATIONS
Biochemical factors
Evidence for dopamine hypothesis |
Supported by studies on effects of drugs:Phenothiazines (Blocks dopamine synapses)Clozapine (Also blocks dopamine receptors)L-Dopa (used for Parkinsons - increases dopamine and leads to similar effects to Sz)ALSOPost Mortems show increased dopaminePET scans - Wong etal found 2x dopamine in Sz brain not using drugs compared to Sz with drugs.
|
BIOLOGICAL EXPLANATIONS
Issues with the dopamine hypothesis
|
Neuroimaging hasnt provided evidenceDrugs do not have the same effects on all people
Post-mortem shows that schiz' that hadnt received anti-psychotics had normal levelsMost post mortems are on Sz who used drugs. Hard to know whether ^ dopamine cause or effect
|
BIOLOGICAL EXPLANATIONS
Neuroanatomical factors
Enlarged ventricles |
Torrey (2002), Schiz have 15% larger ventricles
Could be result of poor brain development/ tissue damage
|
BIOLOGICAL EXPLANATIONS
Neuroanatomical factors
Problems - cause or effect? |
Copolov + Crook (2000), meta-analysis showed overlap between schiz and non-schiz sizes
Lyon et al (1981), as dose of medication increased so did ventricles (so, did Sz cause change or the drugs?)Abnormalities are not found in all sufferers.
|
BIOLOGICAL EXPLANATIONS
Neuroanatomical factors
Crow (1985) suggestion of two types of schizophrenia |
Type 1: genetically inherited. Associated with dopamine dysfunction + possitive symptoms. Responds to antipsychotic medication.
Type 2: neurodevelopmental disorder. Pre-natal/ Perinatal insults. Poor premorbid functioning. Negative symptoms. Doesnt respond wel to drugs.
|
BIOLOGICAL EXPLANATIONS - SUMMARY ISSUE
Diathesis Stress Model |
Have genetic predisposition, but only develops after significant psychological stressors
|
BIOLOGICAL EXPLANATIONS - SUMMARY ISSUE
Reductionist criticism |
Doesn't take into account other factors. Biology trying to find specific explanations even to single genetic level (however, biologists do accept importance of other factors)
|
BIOLOGICAL EXPLANATIONS - SUMMARY ISSUE
Determinism criticism |
Diathesis-stress model is accepted by most biologists
Predisposition-but may not get it.
|